Are Classic Card Games Better Than Apps for Brain Health?

Card games have the better long-term evidence, apps the better trial designs — here is what each actually shows and how to choose.

For brain health, classic card games currently have better evidence behind them than commercial brain-training apps — but the gap is about what has been studied, not about a head-to-head contest. Long-term studies of ordinary games like cards, chess and crosswords show modest links to slower cognitive decline, while regulators and independent reviewers have repeatedly found that app-based brain training mostly makes you better at the app. That said, one specific type of computerized training has the single strongest result in the field: a 20-year trial follow-up linking speed training with booster sessions to lower dementia rates. The honest answer is that a weekly card game is the safer default, and one narrow kind of computer training is the most promising exception.

Medical information disclaimer: This article is for general educational purposes only and does not provide medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always consult a physician or other qualified health professional about symptoms, medications, tests, or treatment decisions.

Table of Contents

What the research on card games actually found

The Lothian Birth Cohort 1936 is a Scottish study that tested the same people at age 11 and again at 70, 73, 76 and 79 — an unusually clean design, because it knows how clever participants were as children. According to the University of Edinburgh's report on the study, the 1,091 participants who more often played non-digital games — cards, chess, bingo, crosswords — showed less cognitive decline between 70 and 79, most clearly in memory and processing speed. The analysis adjusted for childhood cognition, education, social class, sex, activity and health.

Its authors, writing in the *Journals of Gerontology: Series B*, describe the association as small but detectable. Co-author Ian Deary noted that other factors — physical fitness, not smoking — also predict better cognitive ageing, which is a useful reminder that cards are one ingredient, not the recipe. A much larger study points the same way. In the Chinese Longitudinal Healthy Longevity Survey, 11,821 adults aged 65 and over were followed for up to 10 years; those playing cards or mahjong almost daily had a significantly lower dementia risk than rare or never players, with a hazard ratio of 0.63 (95% CI 0.42–0.95).

Why brain-training apps have a weaker record

In 2016, psychologist Daniel Simons and colleagues reviewed 132 journal articles that brain-training companies themselves cited as support. Their verdict, published through the Association for Psychological Science, was that training improves the practiced tasks but there is "no compelling evidence" of cognitive benefits relevant to everyday life. Many of the studies lacked proper control conditions. The pattern held up in later work.

A 2021 meta-analysis in *Neuropsychology Review* pooled 43 computerized cognitive-training studies in older adults and found small significant gains on closely related tasks — "near transfer" — in both healthy and mild-cognitive-impairment groups, but no objective far transfer. Its conclusion was that evidence is insufficient to say such training improves memory, general cognition or everyday functioning. Marketing ran ahead of that evidence. The Federal Trade Commission announced in January 2016 that Lumos Labs would pay $2 million against a suspended $50 million judgment over unsupported claims that Lumosity improved everyday, school and work performance and delayed age-related cognitive decline. Future health claims now require competent and reliable scientific evidence.

The one app-style finding worth taking seriously

The ACTIVE trial is the exception that complicates the simple answer. It randomized 2,832 older adults to ten sessions of memory, reasoning or speed training. At 10 years, published in the *Journal of the American Geriatrics Society*, the reasoning and speed effects on the trained abilities persisted while memory training's did not — and the advantage in daily function was self-reported rather than objectively measured. Then came the long view.

A 20-year follow-up reported in February 2026 by Johns Hopkins Medicine found dementia in 105 of 264 participants (40%) who received speed training plus booster sessions at one and three years, versus 239 of 491 controls (49%) — a hazard ratio of 0.75. Read the details carefully before buying anything. There was no significant long-term benefit for speed training without boosters, and none for memory or reasoning training. That is a specific intervention — visual processing-speed exercises, delivered in a trial, with refresher sessions years later — not a general endorsement of puzzle apps.

Where both sides of the evidence run out

Neither case is as strong as the headlines suggest, and the weaknesses differ. Official guidance reflects that uncertainty rather than resolving it. The World Health Organization's second-edition dementia risk-reduction guidelines, published in July 2026, say cognitive training "may be offered" to older adults with normal cognition or mild cognitive impairment — rating the evidence very low to low and the recommendation conditional.

  • **The card-game evidence is observational.** Participants reported their own play frequency, so people who play more may differ in ways no adjustment captures — healthier, more social, already sharper.
  • **Reverse causation is live.** Early, undiagnosed cognitive change can reduce how often someone plays, which looks identical to playing less causing decline.
  • **No trial has compared the two.** The Altschul paper notes that earlier randomized trials of card and board games were limited by small samples and brief follow-up, so cards have never been tested head to head against apps.
  • **The app evidence is strong where it matters least.** Randomized designs are the gold standard, and they consistently show gains on the trained task rather than in life.

Choosing between them for yourself or a family member

Pick on grounds the evidence can actually support: what the person will keep doing, and what else the activity gives them. For anyone already diagnosed, this is a quality-of-life decision rather than a treatment one. A familiar game that someone can still win is worth more than training software that reminds them daily of what has been lost.

  • **Default to the card game if the choice is social.** Cards and mahjong bring company, conversation and a reason to leave the house; the studied benefit sits inside that whole package, not in the card mechanics alone.
  • **Consider an app if the person plays alone anyway.** Someone who will not join a bridge group loses nothing by using a tablet, provided expectations stay modest.
  • **Treat processing-speed exercises as the better app bet,** given the ACTIVE results — and plan on returning to them periodically, since the 20-year benefit appeared only in the group that had boosters.
  • **Do not pay for promised dementia prevention.** No app has evidence sufficient to make that claim, and one company was fined for trying.
  • **Spend effort on the other predictors too.** Physical fitness and not smoking predict better cognitive ageing in the same cohort that produced the card-game finding.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do crosswords and chess count, or only cards?

The Edinburgh cohort grouped cards, chess, bingo and crosswords together as non-digital games, so the finding applies to the category rather than to cards specifically.

How often would someone need to play?

The strongest dose signal comes from the Chinese cohort, where the lower dementia risk appeared in people playing cards or mahjong almost daily compared with rare or never players.

Is a card game app the same as playing cards?

No study has compared them. The game-related findings measured non-digital play, and the app research measured purpose-built training exercises, so a solitaire app sits in an untested middle ground.

Does any health authority recommend cognitive training?

The WHO's 2026 guidelines say it may be offered to older adults with normal cognition or mild cognitive impairment, but label the recommendation conditional on very low to low quality evidence.


You Might Also Like

HelpDementia.com

Dementia, Alzheimer's, Caregiving & Healthy Aging Guidance

© 2026 HelpDementia.com. All rights reserved.

Educational information only. It is not medical advice and does not replace care from a qualified clinician.