Neonatal intensive care units (NICUs) provide critical care for premature and ill newborns, aiming to support their survival and development. However, questions arise about whether mistakes or adverse events in NICUs can cause cerebral palsy (CP), a lifelong movement disorder caused by non-progressive brain injury or abnormalities in the developing brain.
**Cerebral palsy primarily results from brain injury or abnormal brain development occurring before, during, or shortly after birth**, rather than from errors made during NICU care itself. The brain damage leading to CP is often related to factors such as prematurity, low birth weight, infections, lack of oxygen (hypoxia), or brain hemorrhages that happen around the time of birth or in utero[1][2]. These underlying conditions frequently necessitate NICU admission.
NICUs monitor and treat these vulnerable infants intensively, using advanced technology to track vital signs like heart rate, breathing, and oxygen levels. Research is ongoing to improve early detection of CP by analyzing these physiological data, aiming to identify infants at high risk during their NICU stay to enable earlier intervention[1]. This suggests that NICUs are more often sites of early diagnosis and treatment rather than causes of CP.
**Mistakes in NICU care, while serious and potentially harmful, are not commonly identified as direct causes of cerebral palsy.** Instead, CP is linked to the initial brain injury or abnormality that led to NICU admission. For example, brain injuries such as periventricular leukomalacia (PVL) or intraventricular hemorrhage (IVH) in preterm infants are known risk factors for CP[5]. These injuries can occur due to complications of prematurity or birth trauma rather than NICU errors.
That said, NICU care quality is crucial in minimizing additional brain injury risks. For instance, maintaining adequate oxygenation, preventing infections, and managing blood pressure and hemoglobin levels are essential to avoid exacerbating brain injury[5]. Poor management or medical errors could theoretically worsen an infant’s condition, but such events are distinct from the original cause of CP and are considered preventable complications rather than direct causes of CP.
**Early detection and intervention in NICUs are key to improving outcomes for infants at risk of CP.** Studies show that standardized screening protocols in NICUs can lower the age of CP diagnosis, allowing therapies to begin during critical periods of brain development, which may reduce long-term disability[2][4]. Tools like the PreCEPT system use NICU monitoring data to predict CP risk, highlighting the NICU’s role in early identification rather than causation[1].
Neurodevelopmental follow-up after NICU discharge is also vital. It helps track infants’ progress and identify developmental delays early, enabling timely interventions[3]. However, follow-up practices vary, and some infants with risk factors may not receive adequate monitoring, which can delay diagnosis and treatment.
In summary, **cerebral palsy is caused by brain injury or abnormalities that usually occur before or around birth, not by mistakes made in the NICU.** NICUs play a critical role in caring for at-risk infants, detecting early signs of CP, and initiating interventions that can improve outcomes. While medical errors in NICUs can cause harm, they are not recognized as primary causes of CP but rather as preventable complications that require ongoing quality improvement in neonatal care.
—
[1] University of Virginia News: Pediatrics Professor Lisa Letzkus lead
