There is no authoritative evidence that seniors are being systematically denied organ transplants solely for refusing COVID-19 or other vaccines. While some reports and advocacy groups claim that mandatory vaccination policies have led to denial of organ transplants for unvaccinated individuals, including seniors, these claims lack confirmation from official transplant organizations or regulatory bodies.
One source from the National Vaccine Information Center (NVIC), an organization critical of vaccine mandates, asserts that people who refused COVID-19 vaccines were denied organ transplants[1]. However, this perspective is not corroborated by mainstream medical institutions or transplant regulatory agencies.
The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), which oversees transplant program regulations in the U.S., emphasizes equitable access to organ transplants and uses risk-adjusted models to assess transplant outcomes, but does not list vaccination status as a criterion for transplant eligibility[4]. Transplant centers generally evaluate candidates based on medical urgency, likelihood of transplant success, and ability to adhere to post-transplant care, including immunizations recommended to reduce infection risk.
Medical experts and transplant guidelines recommend COVID-19 vaccination for transplant candidates and recipients because immunosuppressed patients are at higher risk of severe COVID-19 complications[3]. Vaccination improves transplant outcomes by reducing infection risk, but refusal of vaccines is typically addressed through counseling rather than outright denial of transplant listing.
The CDC and other authoritative bodies continue to advocate vaccination as a critical preventive measure, especially for vulnerable populations such as seniors and immunocompromised patients, including those awaiting or having received organ transplants[2][3]. However, there is no official policy mandating vaccination as an absolute prerequisite for transplant eligibility.
In summary, while some anecdotal reports and advocacy groups claim vaccine refusal leads to denial of organ transplants, authoritative sources from transplant regulatory agencies and public health institutions do not support this as standard practice. Transplant eligibility decisions are complex and primarily medically driven, with vaccination status being one factor among many considered to optimize patient outcomes.
—
[1] National Vaccine Information Center (NVIC), August 2025
[2] CBS News, CDC Vaccine Panel Meeting, 2025
[3] Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia Vaccine Education Center, COVID-19 Vaccine Information, July 2025
[4] Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), Increasing Organ Transplant Access Model FAQs, 2025
