Reps in Reserve and Exercise Adherence: Why Leaving Reps on the Table Keeps People Coming Back
When people start an exercise program, they often think they need to push themselves to the absolute limit every single time. This mindset leads many to train to complete failure, where they cannot possibly do another repetition. However, this approach frequently backfires. People get exhausted, sore, and discouraged. They skip workouts. They quit altogether. A better strategy exists, and it centers on a simple concept called reps in reserve, or RIR.
Reps in reserve means intentionally stopping a set before you reach muscular failure. Instead of squeezing out that last possible repetition, you leave a few reps in the tank. For example, if you could theoretically do 10 repetitions of an exercise, you might stop at 7 or 8. This approach might sound counterintuitive to muscle building, but research shows it actually works better for long-term progress and, more importantly, for keeping people consistent with their training.
The connection between reps in reserve and adherence comes down to how exercise feels. When people train to complete failure, they experience extreme fatigue, soreness, and sometimes even post-exercise malaise. Their bodies feel beaten down. Their motivation plummets. They dread the next workout. Over time, this negative experience makes them less likely to show up and train again. Adherence suffers, and without consistency, no training program works.
When people use reps in reserve, the experience changes dramatically. The workout feels challenging but manageable. They finish feeling accomplished rather than destroyed. Their recovery is better because they did not accumulate excessive fatigue. They feel ready to train again sooner. This positive experience creates a cycle where people actually want to come back and exercise again.
Research on exercise adherence supports this approach. One study examined a patient who used self-selected exercise intensity with a focus on maintaining pleasant feelings during workouts. The patient reported positive affective responses to exercise and described feeling motivated to return to training. The key factor was that the intensity was kept at levels that felt good rather than punishing. The patient noted that if a higher recommended load had been imposed, her perceived exertion would have been much higher, resulting in unpleasant responses that would have discouraged her from exercising. This real-world example shows how reps in reserve, by keeping intensity manageable, directly supports adherence.
Another important aspect of reps in reserve relates to recovery between sessions. When you do not train to complete failure, you accumulate less fatigue. This means your body recovers faster. You can train more frequently without overtraining. You can perform more total sets throughout the week while still feeling fresh. This ability to do more work while feeling better creates a powerful combination for both progress and adherence. People who feel recovered and ready to train show up more consistently than people who are constantly sore and tired.
The concept of stimulus to fatigue ratio explains why this works so well. Every exercise creates two things: a stimulus for muscle growth and fatigue that needs to be recovered from. Training to failure maximizes fatigue but does not necessarily maximize the growth stimulus proportionally. Training with reps in reserve allows you to get a high growth stimulus while keeping fatigue lower. This better ratio means you get results without the excessive wear and tear that discourages people from continuing.
Progressive overload, the principle of gradually increasing the demands on your muscles, works perfectly with reps in reserve. Instead of trying to add weight every session or train to failure every time, you can focus on small, consistent improvements. You might add one more repetition this week, increase the weight slightly next week, or reduce your reps in reserve by one rep the following week. These micro-progressions feel achievable and sustainable. People can see progress without feeling like they are constantly fighting against their own limits.
Consistency matters more than perfection in any training program. A person who shows up regularly and trains at moderate intensity will see far better results over time than someone who trains sporadically with maximum intensity. Reps in reserve supports this consistency because it makes training something people can sustain week after week, month after month, and year after year. The person who trains at 80 percent effort three times per week for a year will progress more than the person who trains at 100 percent effort twice per month before burning out.
The psychological component cannot be overlooked. Exercise adherence depends heavily on how people feel about their workouts. When training feels punishing, people avoid it. When training feels challenging but achievable, people embrace it. Reps in reserve creates the second experience. People feel like they accomplished something without feeling destroyed. They feel capable and strong rather than weak and exhausted. This positive psychology keeps people engaged with their training.
For people returning to exercise after illness or injury, reps in reserve becomes even more important. These individuals need to rebuild confidence in their bodies and establish positive associations with exercise. Training to failure would be counterproductive. Instead, starting with conservative intensity and reps in reserve allows them to experience success, feel good about their workouts, and gradually build back their fitness. This approach supports both physical recovery and psychological readiness to continue training.
The practical application is straightforward. When you perform an exercise, ask yourself how many more repetitions you could theoretically do. If you could do three more reps, you have three reps in reserve. Aim to stop at two or three reps in reserve for most of your training. This keeps the workout challenging enough to drive progress but not so intense that it creates excessive fatigue or negative feelings. Over weeks and months, you can gradually reduce your reps in reserve as you get stronger, creating progressive overload without ever needing to train to complete failure.
Tracking your training helps with this approach. When you write down your weights, reps, and how many reps you had in reserve, you create accountability and visibility into your progress. You can see that you are getting stronger even though you are not training to failure. This objective evidence of progress reinforces adherence because people can see that the method works.
The strongest and most consistent exercisers are not those who train the hardest in individual sessions. They are the ones who train consistently over years, applying small progressions regularly and maintaining a sustainable approach. Reps in reserve enables this long-term success by making exercise something people can stick with indefinitely. It removes the boom-and-bust cycle where people train hard, burn out, quit, and then start over. Instead, it creates a sustainable rhythm where people train regularly, feel good about their workouts, and keep coming back.
Sources
